New Zealand Police has acknowledged today’s Supreme Court decision to quash the convictions of James Wilson and Mark Hoggart in relation to the 1987 aggravated robbery of the Red Fox Tavern and the murder of publican, Christopher Bush.
The Supreme Court delivered its ruling in the case two years of deliberating, finding there was no reliable evidence to prove the pair were at the scene of the crime.
In a statement, Detective Superintendent Dave Lynch said Police respect the Court’s decision and will carefully review the jdgment.
“The differing conclusions reached by the High Court, Court of Appeal and Supreme Court illustrate the complexity of the evidential issues considered throughout these proceedings,” said Det Supt Lynch.
“The offending at the Red Fox Tavern on 24 October 1987 was a tragic event that resulted in the death of Mr Bush and had a profound impact on his family, friends, staff members who were present, and the wider community. We recognise that today’s decision will be difficult for many people connected to the case, particularly Mr Bush’s family, who have lived with the consequences of this crime for almost four decades.”
Mr Bush (pictured) was gunned down at the Maramarua pub on October 24, 1987, with two balaclava-clad offenders fleeing the scene with more than $30,000 in cash.
One of the men acquitted today, Filthy Few gang President, James Wilson, has a string of previous convictions including for the murder of a former partner in 1999. He had also been convicted of other aggravated robberies.
The investigation into the tavern robbery and homicide was extensive, spanning many years and multiple investigative reviews.
“Police remain proud of the dedication and professionalism of the investigators who worked tirelessly to seek answers on behalf of the victim, his family, and the community,” said Det Supt Lynch.
He said the Supreme Court’s decision does not diminish the seriousness of the offending or the commitment shown by investigators over many years.
“Police undertook the prosecution based on the evidence available and in accordance with our obligations under the criminal justice system.”
“As the matter has now been determined by the Supreme Court, Police will take time to consider the judgment and its findings.
“Our thoughts remain with the family of Christopher Bush and all those affected by these events,” Det Supt Lynch said.
